Meanwhile, Winona Ryder—who had been cast as Michael Corleone’s teenage daughter over actors like Julia Roberts and Madonna—famously dropped out of the project before shooting even one scene, citing exhaustion. Actresses such as Annabella Sciorra and Laura San Giacomo were considered, it was reported at the time, but Coppola felt they were too old for the role. So instead, he cast his daughter, Sofia Coppola. Her performance in the film was widely panned and mocked for years to come.
“It was hard because I was 18 and the last thing you want to do at that age is listen to what your parents say,” Sofia said in a 2011 interview. “My dad was directing me, so it was awkward because I am not naturally an actress. But I just wanted to try everything, and wasn’t expecting that so many people would look at it. I grew up with The Godfather as a familiar thing, but to me, it wasn’t this iconic masterpiece. It was a learning experience. But since I never wanted to be an actress it wasn’t devastating for me that people generally weren’t too fond of me being in it. After all, it was good because these kinds of experiences make you stronger.”
As Coppola mentioned in the press release, the title was a sore point as well. “It was not meant to be part of a trilogy, but rather a coda to the first two films, and we wished it could be given a different title, one more appropriate,” Coppola wrote in a new introduction to The Godfather novel released last year. “Neither of us [Coppola or Puzo] had the power to insist on our title but in my mind, the film will always be called The Death of Michael Corleone.”
Over the years, Coppola has discussed the third film and how he would go back and change it given the chance. “There’s a cut I want to make that would be 14 minutes shorter,” Coppola told Deadline in an interview last year. “Usually, I go back and make them longer. This would be effective, and it makes the ending break your heart. Jim Gianopulos is the head of Paramount. An extremely nice man. And so what I want to say to them is if you allow me this, you won’t have to pay me.”
The director, now 81, also said he hoped the new cut would better serve his daughter.
“I want to show Sofia a new version, because she is so beautiful in it and so touching,” he told Deadline. “She wasn’t an actress. But she was the real thing, playing that 19-year-old Italian girl in love with her own cousin [played in the film by Andy Garcia]. Godfather III as The Death of Michael Corleone is doubly painful because at the end he doesn’t die, but he does worse than die. He loses everything he loves—and he lives. There are certain things in life that are worse than death.”
In the film, Sofia’s character, Mary Corleone, is shot and killed during an assassination attempt on her father’s life. It’s an especially tragic end, as Michael (Pacino) had previously sworn on his children’s lives to clean up his criminal ways. The Godfather Part III itself ends with a brief epilogue set in at an undetermined time in the future in which Michael dies alone, in a sequence that recalls how his father, Don Vito Corleone, died in the original film.
“I believe if I do this new cut that her performance will be very touching as a little 19-year-old girl. That’s one of the things that can be so improved,” Coppola said last year, before adding, “I believe that in a new version of The Death of Michael Corleone, Sofia’s performance will vindicate her.” Sounds like Coppola is finally ready to settle all family business, once and for all.
More Great Stories From Vanity Fair
— Angela Davis and Ava DuVernay on Black Lives Matter
— Celebrating 22 Activists and Visionaries on the Forefront of Change
— Here’s Your First Look at The Haunting of Bly Manor
— Ben Affleck Will Return as Batman in The Flash
— Ta-Nehisi Coates Guest-Edits THE GREAT FIRE, a Special Issue
— Behind the Scenes of the Shocking Twist in Below Deck
— How Hollywood Shaped Kamala Harris and Doug Emhoff’s Marriage
— From the Archive: Young and Clueless
— Not a subscriber? Join Vanity Fair to receive the September issue, plus full digital access, now.