Dexter Morgan’s return to the Miami scene continues to hit all the nostalgic notes while carving out a new path that delves deep into his origins and the relationships shaping him.
With Dexter: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 2, “Kid in a Candy Store,” and Dexter: Original Sin Season 1 Episode 3, “Miami Vice,” the show takes us on a whirlwind journey of murder, manipulation, and some deeply awkward family dynamics.
But does it all come together as the beginnings of the Dexter we know? Let’s dig in.
Warning: Spoilers ahead!
Dexter’s first days at Miami Metro are a mixed bag — literally.
Between making coffee runs and delivering veggie trays, our beloved blood-spatter enthusiast is learning the ropes in the most humbling of ways.
Tanya Martin (Sarah Michelle Gellar, bringing just the right amount of no-nonsense energy) gives Dexter his first taste of crime scene analysis, sparking that signature passion for blood spatter patterns.
But it’s not all smooth sailing; watching him bungle his attempts to fit in with gallows humor and failed jokes reminds us how much of an outsider Dexter has always been, even when he tries his hardest to blend in.
Still, the seeds of his future brilliance are evident.
His detailed observations at crime scenes and relentless curiosity highlight the natural talent that will later become his lifeblood (pun intended).
Watching Dexter’s excitement — masked, of course, by his awkward charm — at being part of the action is fascinating.
His enthusiasm when handed a crime scene is like a kid on Christmas morning, and it’s darkly hilarious when he compares a dead body to a gift-wrapped present.
It’s moments like these that show how well the series balances humor and horror.
Meanwhile, Harry is grappling with his own demons, trying to navigate fatherhood, guilt, and the Pandora’s box he opened by teaching Dexter to control his murderous urges.
Harry’s moral gymnastics are a highlight as he wrestles with the realization that his guidance is creating a monster he can’t entirely control.
The flashbacks with Laura Moser — Dexter’s biological mother — add layers to Harry’s motivations and guilt.
His affair with Laura, his failure to protect her, and his decision to take in her boys (at least Dexter) are emotionally charged revelations that reframe Harry’s dynamic with Dexter.
Is Harry a flawed savior or the architect of his own downfall? The show invites us to decide, and the answer isn’t simple.
Debra’s storyline, though lighter in tone, brings its own set of complications.
Her attempt to pawn the nurse’s earrings (Dexter’s trophy from his first kill) sets off a chain reaction that underscores the chaos Dexter’s “dark passenger” brings to everyone around him.
Debra’s naivety and desire for acceptance are painfully relatable, but her involvement in Dexter’s secrets is a ticking time bomb.
And let’s not forget Sofia, whose crush on Dexter adds an awkward layer to an already messy situation.
Poor Dexter — he’s better at dodging police suspicions than teenage infatuations.
Another intriguing addition is Maria LaGuerta’s introduction as a new detective. Her no-nonsense approach and willingness to challenge the status quo at Miami Metro immediately set her apart.
Watching her navigate the department’s politics while tackling cold cases adds a fresh perspective and hints at future conflicts.
Her determination to shine a light on overlooked victims — particularly those from marginalized communities — is a stark contrast to the department’s usual priorities, and it’s a thread worth watching as the season unfolds.
Dexter’s hunt for Ferrar, his second victim, showcases his evolution as a killer.
The meticulous planning, the fake ID with the hilariously on-brand “Patrick Bateman” alias, and his ability to manipulate Ferrar into a false sense of security highlight his growing confidence.
However, the Jai Alai court kill feels unnecessarily risky — a public venue is an odd choice for someone as calculated as Dexter.
Then again, he’s still new to being a serial killer, and if Harry had tagged along as he wanted, it’s safe to say things wouldn’t have unfolded this way.
Of course, when Harry eventually finds out the details, you can bet he’ll put an end to that kind of recklessness.
Still, the scene delivers the gruesome, plastic-sheeted spectacle fans have come to expect.
And Dexter’s choice to ditch his trophy-taking habit after Harry’s warning shows a rare moment of self-restraint — at least for now.
The parallel storylines of Jimmy Powell’s kidnapping and Harry’s flashbacks to his work with Laura tie the episodes together thematically.
Both explore the cost of sacrifice and the moral compromises people make in the name of justice.
Harry’s justifications for his actions — whether protecting Laura or guiding Dexter — are riddled with contradictions, making him one of the show’s most complex characters.
And while Jimmy Powell’s fate remains unresolved by the end of “Miami Vice,” the gruesome hint of what might have happened to him keeps the tension high.
Ultimately, these two episodes serve as a compelling exploration of Dexter’s formative years, showing how his environment, relationships, and choices shape the man — and the killer — he’s destined to become.
The show’s ability to blend dark humor, character-driven drama, and edge-of-your-seat suspense is as sharp as ever.
Dexter’s journey into darkness is only just beginning, and it’s going to be a wild ride (and who doesn’t love all that 90s nostalgia? The music choices are spot on.)
What did you think of this two-episode drop? Are you enjoying the deep dive into Dexter’s early days, or are there elements you wish the show would explore more? Let us know in the comments below!
Watch Dexter: Original Sin Online
