10 Best Hair Ties For Men – Elastics That Don’t Pull 2023

Taking care of longer hair is more than just finding a quality shampoo and conditioner, it’s about finding the best hair ties for men. With most hair ties being marketed towards women, it can be confusing to know which ones are best for guys.

The good news is, men’s hair is no different than women’s. Hair ties that women love are just as great for men. But there are hair ties men might prefer based on color, hair type, hold, and how well they comfortably secure your hair. There are even brands designed specifically with men in mind, which is pretty cool. Looking at you, Hair Ties for Guys.

Whether you need a hair tie for sports or personal style, I’ve got you covered. The hair ties on this list are highly rated, elastic, and secure, with no pulling, tugging or snagging if you wear them right. As someone who’s been wearing hair ties for decades, you can trust me.

Now let’s take a look at the 10 best hair ties for guys below.

Key Takeaways 

In search of the best hair ties for men, I pored over tons of websites, reviews, and photos to create this list. As a hair tie wearer, I want to pass on all the knowledge I possess.

The best elastic hair ties for men are strong, secure, and gentle, without pulling or tugging on the hair. Ultimately, Gimme Beauty Hair Ties took my top spot because they fulfill all those requirements, plus they have the ability to withstand loads of pressure.

I also appreciate that they come in various widths for all hair types and thickness. If you have thin, fine hair, take a look at Goody’s Non-slip Hair Ties and the tiny hair bands from Heliums.

Why it’s Great: If there’s an elite hair tie for guys out there, these are it. Gimme Beauty makes a seamless microfiber hair tie that’s secure, gentle, and strong, with the ability to withstand up to 70 pounds of pressure (standard hair ties typically withstand around 8). I doubt anyone’s hair is that heavy, but it’s definitely comforting to know. Depending on the thickness of your hair, there are five different widths to choose from. I’ve linked the thick version, but here is a thinner option. As for styling, choose from several attractive color palettes in addition to plain black.

How it feels: With a patented design for elasticity, the bands are composed of hundreds of microfiber elastics that work together to spread tension evenly over the head.  I personally hate when my ponytail pulls in certain places, so this is pretty fantastic. Whether you’re wearing a ponytail or bun, they feel great.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: I do wish they were a little bit cheaper, as each purchase comes with only 6 hair ties, but so long as you don’t lose them, you’re fine—these hair ties aren’t likely to break.

Hair Type: All  | Color: Various | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: For a budget buy, these hair ties sure have a cult-like following. At first glance, there’s nothing special about them, but as soon as I put them in my hair, I understood what the fuss was about. They’re creaseless, so there’s no weird bump or marks in your hair when you take it out, and they hold up well over dozens of uses.

How it feels: Kitsch makes some of the best hair ties for men because they’re highly durable and comfortable, thanks to soft and gentle recycled nylon. Yet they have a strong grip, thanks to special gripping technology, so you never feel like your ponytail is going to fall out.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: Besides black and gray, there aren’t very many colors to choose from. The thinner version does come with 20 in a pack, however, so you’re definitely getting bang for your buck. That had me worried they would break or stretch out easily, but not so. They bounce back like a charm.

Hair Type: All  | Color: Black, gray, blush | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: Hair Ties for Guys debuted on Shark Tank as a hair tie created for men looking for strong, manly-looking hair ties to fill a major hole in the market. Forget about leaving it to your haircut to express your personal style, now you can choose from various styles and designs  to show off your tastes, like grays, vikings, and even wood grain. How’s that for manly?

How it feels: As for performance, they work. I found that my hair didn’t pull in weird places, and it definitely didn’t snag or rip when wrapping or unwrapping. Overall, they’re very comfortable in the hair. Considering they can hold up to 80 pounds of weight, I’d say they’re pretty strong, too.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: They aren’t exactly luxury, but Hair Ties for Guys are more expensive than most. However, these puppies work, and aren’t likely to break. So long as you can hold onto them, you’re golden.

Hair Type: All  | Color: Black, various patterns | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: I’m not going to lie, I was skeptical of these hair ties at first. That woven material and ornamental bead seemed awfully uncomfortable, but luckily, I have no problem being proven wrong. These hair ties are comfortable, durable, and have a superb amount of stretch. I think it’s great for the bohemian, laid back guy. Perfect for a man bun. Plus, it can double as a bracelet.

How it feels: Once I got it in my hair, I realized how much the woven design actually encouraged a strong grip for my ponytail. It’s much softer than it appears. And the bead is small enough that you don’t feel it, and it doesn’t interfere with your hairstyle.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: Because of their larger circumference, I don’t recommend this hair tie for those with thin hair. However, if your hair is medium to thick, they’ll serve you well.

Hair Type: Medium-Thick  | Color: 38 options | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: Next to scrunchies, this is my preferred style of hair tie, so you know it’s one of the best hair ties for men. The unique spiral shape is a relatively new design in the hair tie world, and it’s the best at distributing pressure evenly, in my opinion. There’s no weird pulling, like ever. They’re also backed by science. Proven to cause 31% less damage than ordinary elastics.

How it feels: They’re super strong, very comfortable, and never make my hair tangle, no matter how poorly I might pull it out. My preferred way to wear them is in a bun or low ponytail.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: I will say, they aren’t great for making a tight, high ponytail because they aren’t very tight (unless you have crazy thick hair).

Tip: When unwrapping your hair, try not to just pull it straight out. You will lose hairs that way. Instead, unwrap each loop, if you wrapped it around your hair more than once, and gently remove.

Hair Type: All | Color: Black, clear, brown, pink | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: If you’re that dude that’s prone to losing things, then you definitely need to buy hair ties in bulk. Even though you get a bunch of eBoot bands for cheap, they’re still one of the best hair ties for men. They’re super thick and squishy, which is great if you have medium to thick hair, and they feel great while wearing, even when exercising.

How it feels: They’re the only hair tie on this list that’s made from cotton, which is actually a great choice for a hair band. This makes them soft and durable as they neatly compress your hair. They’re also seamless so they won’t cause any annoying creases when you take them out.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: They do stretch out easily, which isn’t ideal, but one gem of a reviewer noted that if you rinse them in warm water and let them dry, they return to their original size. Great.

Hair Type: Medium-thick | Color: Black | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: These feel a little bit like a knock-off of Gimme Beauty hair ties, but I’m not mad at it. They do their job well, and I do enjoy the name of the brand for dudes. That being said, next to a hair wax or paste, nothing holds the hair back quite like these hair ties. They were specifically designed to hold curly and thick hair types, but this also makes them great for sport. You can jump, dance, and even flip over to your heart’s content and not have to worry that these hair ties will slip.

How it feels: These puppies are super thick and stretchy. I hate to speak in absolutes, but I doubt they’ll ever rip or snag your hair. If you have thick hair that you need to throw in a bun, this is the way to go. And they give good grip on even the silkiest, slipperiest hair.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: In terms of bang for your buck, you only get three hair ties in one purchase, which isn’t the best deal. But if you have thick, curly hair, or need the best hair tie for working out, you can’t go wrong here.

Hair Type: Thick  | Color: Black, blonde, gray, blue, brown, etc. | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: Every guy needs a good hair tie in their arsenal of products, but it can be tough to find if you’re focused on sustainability. Luckily, there’s brands like Terra Ties that put a lot of energy into creating a strong, secure hair tie with the environment in mind. All of the materials used are ethically sourced, right down to the packaging, which is recyclable, by the way. Their products are plastic-free and the hair ties are entirely biodegradable. Sweet.

 How it feels: As for hold, they do the job well. They don’t pull, slip, or cause damage to your hair. And they’re strong, with the ability to withstand up to 19 pounds of tension.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: Even though they’re rather thin, reviewers with thick, curly hair agree they do a great job at securing the hair.

Hair Type: All | Color: Black | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: I’m not sure why these hair ties are labeled for women when there’s nothing gendered about them, especially considering you can buy them in black and brown. Marketing aside, Goody Non-slip ties are great thanks to slide-proof construction made from a thick inner core and an outer braid design. This makes them flexible and strong, regardless of whether your hair is silky soft, fine, or thin. Unlike rubber hair ties, which hold well but are known for ripping out hair when removed, these hair ties are gentle and won’t pull.

How it feels: These are great hair ties for guys, especially if you have fine hair. All hair types can use them, but I love them for fine-haired folks because of their comfortable, yet substantial grip.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: If your hair is particularly thick and if you have curls that are tight, you might be better off with another option, like Burlybands or even Invisibobble. However, if slippage is an issue for you, you’ll love the way these puppies grip.

Hair Type: Fine, All  | Color: Black, brown, colors | Form: Elastic

Why it’s Great: Small hair ties are a must for guys with really thin hair. Heliums come in a variety of colors to match your hair color, which is great if you prefer a hair tie that’s more discrete. They’re cheap, easy to wear, and because they’re small, they work well for hair styles like braids.

How it feels: If I can give one piece of advice, it’s to avoid rubber hair ties. They pull out your hair like nobody’s business. That being said, I like these small hair ties from Helium because they’re rubber wrapped in polyester, so they won’t tug or pull at your hair at all.

Flaws but not dealbreakers: I wish I could say that they didn’t ever lose their elasticity, but after a few uses, they begin to wear out. Fortunately, they’re cheap, and come with a whopping 48 hair ties per pack. Even if you’re new to the hair tie game, you probably know how easy it is to lose them, so it’s nice to have plenty.

Hair Type: Thin  | Color: Various | Form: Elastic

What To Look For In The Best Hair Ties For Men

Color

The best hair ties for guys should come with color options, though plain black is always a safe choice. However, different colors and patterns are great for matching to your outfit or even a sports jersey. If you prefer a low profile, look for hair ties that match your hair color, like the ones from Heliums.

Material

While most hair ties are elastic, they can be made from a variety of materials that have various effects on the hair. Spiral elastic, microfiber, and nylon are very gentle yet strong and won’t leave a crease behind. Please, avoid rubber directly on the hair but it’s okay when wrapped in another material.

Hair Thickness 

As a general rule of thumb, the thicker your hair, the thicker your hair tie should be and the larger the circumference. There are slight exceptions, but generally this is standard. If your hair is thick and long, look for a hair tie around ½ inches thick. Thinner ties with a smaller circumference work for thinner, finer hair types.

Why you should trust us

As a fashion and grooming writer for Fashionbeans, I use my years of expertise in the fashion and beauty world to inform my work. I conducted hours of research to find the best hair ties for men, and even used my own experience as a hair tie wearer to imbue this list with personal knowledge and insight. Out of hundreds of different hair ties out there, I can assure you, these are the best of the very best, from price and accessibility to comfort and security.

Final Verdict 

The best hair ties for men should be suited to your particular hair type and thickness. They should be gentle yet strong, with plenty of elastic to hold your hair that bounces back when it’s not. My favorite hair ties for men are Gimme Beauty Hair Ties because they’re wildly durable, soft, and they never rip, pull, tug, or even crease your hair.